Flaw!! In TLB, the time periods are wrong

[Skulblaka_Shur'tugal]

I found a flaw for the Last Battle! Originally, C.S. Lewis wanted the story to happen five years after the Silver Chair. But, according to Jill when she was talking to Tirian when they meet him, it had barely been a year! Don't believe me? Read it for yourself!

[Tsukiko]

really/? thats interesting

[LifeMaiden]

I found a flaw for the Last Battle! Originally, C.S. Lewis wanted the story to happen five years after the Silver Chair. But, according to Jill when she was talking to Tirian when they meet him, it had barely been a year! Don't believe me? Read it for yourself!


There are a few flaws regarding the differences in time I think. I'll have to go back adn check that out.

[Princess_Iliana]

There are a few flaws regarding the differences in time I think. I'll have to go back adn check that out.

I think that has to do with him writing most of it out of Chronilogical order.

[QueenSusanofNarnia]

i agree w/ Princess_Iliana

[Lioness_Aslan]

I found a flaw for the Last Battle! Originally, C.S. Lewis wanted the story to happen five years after the Silver Chair. But, according to Jill when she was talking to Tirian when they meet him, it had barely been a year! Don't believe me? Read it for yourself!
:eek: Hey you're right!!

[Malacandra]

Sorry, in what way is this a "flaw" rather than "a change of mind by the author"? Does something somewhere get ruined?

[Narborg]

Really? Where doe it say that?

[Aslan's Beloved Daughter]

^_^
weird. but then again Lewis could have changed his mind...

[Narborg]

Im prity shere it doent say that. Where abouts?