confusion ***TLB Spoilers*** Do Eustace & Jill die?

[office]

i know that peter edmund and lucy die....but do jill and eustace?
im reading lb right now

[Apple_Of_Life29]

why dont you finish it? lol yeah they dont know it but they died in the trainw reck also.

[Tsukiko]

Yeah they all died in the train wreck

[theorangejello]

hmm k..
know i get the story..
wait actually i don't i knew something happened to them.. but i couldn't place it.
so in the end they are totally dead.. and narnia is like heaven??? :confused:

[theorangejello]

in the end of the series.. the last book. it seems as if peter, edmund, lucy and jill eustace died..
i'm really confused.. but how and why.. and is aslan kinda like god or jesus (i'm not christian btw) ??? is narnia related to heaven.. i've been pondering over this for some time. so yea.. some explaining would help.

[Apple_Of_Life29]

they died in a train wreck just after jill and eustace went narnia. and since they were dead they went to narnia in heaven ~that means that there is a copy of every place on earth in heaven~i think Aslan is supposed to represent Christ.

[Apple_Of_Life29]

the real narnia is in heaven~the narnia that lucy gets thru the wardrobe is a COPY of narnia, with bad things included

[theorangejello]

the real narnia is in heaven~the narnia that lucy gets thru the wardrobe is a COPY of narnia, with bad things included


aah k .. i kinda understand knoww.

[theorangejello]

they died in a train wreck just after jill and eustace went narnia. and since they were dead they went to narnia in heaven ~that means that there is a copy of every place on earth in heaven~i think Aslan is supposed to represent Christ.


that's actually quite sad.. so um susan is the only person alive??? wow.. very sad. :(

[Lady Callandra]

Because Susan stopped believing in Narnia, so she didn't go with them.

[theorangejello]

Because Susan stopped believing in Narnia, so she didn't go with them.


hmm so its like susan turned atheist.. i mean if narnia is like heaven.

[holyboy]

iMove to book section.

[theorangejello]

iMove to book section.


k .. how.???

[inkspot]

HolyBoy (HB) did it for you, because he is a mod, he can do such things.

From the Christian perspective, it's not really sad for the friends of Narnia to be removed from this world and taken into the next one -- it's only sad for Susan, because she is left behind.

It's the general thought that in LWW, Aslan represents Jesus, and Edmund represents us -- people who have done bad acts and need to be forgiven. The Christian perspective is that the death of Christ provided a way for us to be forgiven of prior bad acts (what we call sin) so that we can be reunited with God.

In LWW, Aslan's death -- because of the Deep Magic -- did this same thing for Edmund: provided a way for his bad acts to be forgiven so he could be restored to his family, and placed in a relationship/friendship with Aslan.

reading through all the books, you may have noticed Aslan sometimes says the children who are too old to come back to Narnia must learn to know him in their world -- it's the general thought Lewis meant they would come to know our Aslan, the earth's Aslan, Jesus Christ.

[theorangejello]

HolyBoy (HB) did it for you, because he is a mod, he can do such things.

From the Christian perspective, it's not really sad for the friends of Narnia to be removed from this world and taken into the next one -- it's only sad for Susan, because she is left behind.

It's the general thought that in LWW, Aslan represents Jesus, and Edmund represents us -- people who have done bad acts and need to be forgiven. The Christian perspective is that the death of Christ provided a way for us to be forgiven of prior bad acts (what we call sin) so that we can be reunited with God.

In LWW, Aslan's death -- because of the Deep Magic -- did this same thing for Edmund: provided a way for his bad acts to be forgiven so he could be restored to his family, and placed in a relationship/friendship with Aslan.

reading through all the books, you may have noticed Aslan sometimes says the children who are too old to come back to Narnia must learn to know him in their world -- it's the general thought Lewis meant they would come to know our Aslan, the earth's Aslan, Jesus Christ.


aaah okay .. i see...

[jonathanruiz209]

the new narnia reminds me of the New Jerusalem...:)

[inkspot]

And Imerge this Thread with the one about Eustace and Jill, as the topics are more or less the same.
:)

[Bramblefox]

The LB always makes me cry at the end, because it all sounds so beautiful and a great place to be. Just thought I might let you know that :)

[Balloonpumpsrus]

wow i should really reread the books... i'm getting a bit lost... however i am remembering stuff as i read this thread... :confused:

[Ankle Slicer]

Yes, they get killed in a train accident.

[White Claw the wolf]

Well in the book says that everyone (Peter,Edmund,Lucy,Eustace,Jill,prof.Kirke and Polly) died, except for Susan, I think it was sad that Susan didnt travel to Narnia because she didnt believe in Narnia anymore, she's one of my favorite characteres, but i like to think taht when she dies, she may return to Narnia as Queen Susan. Its a bit sad the fact that Susan didnt die(it sounds cruel, i know XD) and travel to Narnia because all her brothers and their parents and lucy died and she become lonely in England...however, all 7 books are great, I like them a lot and the end of the last book was great! :)

[inkspot]

A few people have written stories about what happens to Susan after TLB. A lot of us are pulling for her to return to Narnia!
:)