Who'd win in a fight, Edmund or Eustace?

[office]

Okay i mean rude Edmund and Eustace and no swords.

[Narniarules]

I think Edmund because he is stronger... I think

[makeascenerachel]

Edmund duh!!!!! :D (cuz Skandar is stong)

[Wings of Vanity]

ohh definetely edmund without a doubt!!

[♣Teh Deviant♣]

Edmund...and this has nothing to do with Skandar...
1] He's older

2] He's blonde :rolleyes: :confused: :rolleyes:

3] He's.....a King..pssfttt :p

4] He's braver, I mean, he didnt need to be turned into a dragon to make sense of himself! Thats enough proof rite there!

5] Most importantly, he's a PEVENSIE!

[Faun 3.0]

I say Edmund.

Skandar could probably beat up any unlucky kid that would play Eustace

[Kate12whisper13]

You have made ALOT of these topics!

[Danny Darnia]

i think Eustace will win. Coz he has sharp mouth and I think he has lots of dirty words that kept in his mind :D

[Lady Larien]

well actually i think they both would knock each other out at the same time so yeah a say DRAW!

[Danny Darnia]

well actually i think they both would knock each other out at the same time so yeah a say DRAW!

If Ed knocking Eustace, he will cry and run hiding, and he'll attack Ed with his words :D Then, his parents will came and blame the whole things to Ed. So......Eustace is a hard enemy for Ed and he still win.
It's not because of Eustace's parents help.....but it called STRATEGY :D
What a bad and funny idea to met them in a children battle

[Oddish]

Please remember, we're talking nasty pre-Aslan Edmund vs. obnoxious pre-Aslan Eustace. But I have to put my money on Edmund, because he's slightly older, and because he has Peter periodically bashing him for being mean to Lucy, so he's more used to pain. Eustace had never even had his fanny swatted. However, the fight consists of Edmund smacking Eustace one time and Eustace running off shouting "Alberta! Edmund hit me!" -- I hardly call that a significant victory.

[Narniarules]

Obviously Edmund because he is strong he is older and he is a king of narnia and he has good ablities to beat Eustace because Eustace is just an ordimary boy who has a bad mouth but Edmund can just beat Eustace up..

[Sharlene]

I think Edmund would def. win the fight.

[miss_elizabeth]

of course edmund hell yeah...and he's **** hot too.

[Neevil]

In VotDT, Eustace is described as "a puny little person who couldn't have stood up to even Lucy, let alone Edmund, in a fight". (lol i love that sentence) So I definatly say Edmund would win :p

[ABright5]

2] He's blonde :rolleyes: :confused: :rolleyes:


Okkkay. Which planet do you live on?
Lol


I definately say Edmund

[-Forever_Young-]

In VotDT, Eustace is described as "a puny little person who couldn't have stood up to even Lucy, let alone Edmund, in a fight". (lol i love that sentence) So I definatly say Edmund would win :p
I love that sentence too! So probably Ed... yeah, Eustace would run off crying LOL... :p

[Protofan]

Edmund would win. 'Nuff said.

[Adanedhel]

Edmund no doubt, hands down.

[lollypops36]

ed would win cos eustace is kinda a bit of a girl and yer

[<Turkish Delight>]

Edmund would win for sure because he is a king in narnia and is much stronger than Eustace and is older too.

[QueenSusanofNarnia]

Edmund betta make us proud!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He betta win..or i'll beat him up (jk)

[ABright5]

Edmund betta make us proud!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He betta win..or i'll beat him up (jk)

It's Just a hypothetical question
http://www.madjbright.co.uk/Alex/Lol.dat

[LifeMaiden]

I'm about twenty pages now into the Dawn Treader and I can tell you already LOL that Eustace would LOSE. He's a crybaby and a sissy.

[Love_Punch]

Edmund would totally win!Eustace is a wuss!

[DestinyLies]

Edmund wouldSOO win!!!!!

[QueenSusanofNarnia]

It's Just a hypothetical question
http://www.madjbright.co.uk/Alex/Lol.dat

i know..lol...(I like hte little lol sign..:))

[Queen_Lucy]

ed, i think. he's had more exercise in battles than eustace, hasn't he?

[Skandargrl4ever]

as much as i love skandar, do you think he could beat a 19 year old?

[ABright5]

as much as i love skandar, do you think he could beat a 19 year old?

Eustace is younger than Lucy isn't he?
http://www.madjbright.co.uk/Alex/Lol.dat

[office]

yes he is by one year.

[ABright5]

yes he is by one year.
So why do people start talking about him being 19?
http://www.madjbright.co.uk/Alex/Lol.dat

[Tootsie]

I think Edmund would but for these reasons:

1) He's experienced and works through strategy, not just swinging and hoping he hits the other person.

2) He's a king. Enough said.

3) I think he's been in more battles than Eustace, actually Eustace hasn't been in any...except for the last battle.

But, it depends on WHEN this fight would take place. In case you haven't noticed, Eustace is just as good as Edmund in the last book as Edmund ever was. He was much more mature and stronger than in TDT, so if it's there I can't say. But in PC or in TDT or in LWW even, Edmund would win, just because he's older. Older people stink. :D

;)

[the freak sisters]

I think Edmund because in VDT it says that Euctace coulnd't have even stood up to Lucy in a fight!!!

[Tootsie]

*snigger* I know, that was funny. I'd actually like to see Edmund and Eustace fight. Lewis should have made them start fist fighting while in the bedroom before they got sucked into the portrait. That would have been HILARIOUS.

*dies*

[LifeMaiden]

Poor Eustace couldn't help being such a sissy. There was almost something really comical about his character.

[ABright5]

Poor Eustace couldn't help being such a sissy. There was almost something really comical about his character.

"There once was a boy called Eustace Clarence Scrubb, and he almost deserved it"

It says it all.

(The quote might not be exact. I don't have my book with me)

[PeterC]

Well, Edmund kills things (I think) in the first movie, so him.

[Twilightdryadhobbit]

Eustace was a big fat whiner, Edmund has more of a temper, so my bet's on him

[Protofan]

Edmund. 'Nuff said.

[she-elfwarrior19]

Why would the fight in the first place??? Or why do you think they should fight?

[Crimson]

hard 2 say...they are both strong but i remember in VoTD it said Eusatce could not win a fight against Edmund, let alone Lucy :D but, if they were on earth i would say Ed but if they were in Narnia..hmmm i could not choose

[*Hobbit*]

is it any question that edmund would win

[Something Wicked!!!~.^]

Is there even a doubt? Of course it'd be Edmund- though I'm thinking of the Ed from the books or the old movies boy was he yummy not like this new dude he seems a bit idon'know- just not like I pictured him(had to check myself before I said anything bad infronta all these Skanderites) :D

[Elf Of The Grey Havens]

King Ed versus and Eustace, Ed. But England Ed versus England Eustace, probably Eustace, he seems like the kind of person who would be very self-concious. And would probably go to health clubs and stuff. And get muscly.

[~Sweet Angel~]

I think Edmund would because if I'm correct, he's stronger and older that Eustace.

[MRS._William_Moseley]

I don't know. Eustace sounds like a snotty kid in the book. And Edmund is older. So I still don't know...there's two way's this could go???? :rolleyes:

[Oddish]

If we're talking King Edmund vs. pre-Narnia Eustace, it's no doubt. I mean, pre-Narnia Peter would get whomped by post-Narnia Edmund. So the only way pre-Narnia Eustace could prevail against King Edmund the Just would be if he whipped out a Thompson .45-caliber submachine gun (yes, they were around in the '40's) and blasted him with it at close range. Yes, he'd probably miss most of the shots, but those things hold 50 bullets and by sheer luck, he'd probably hit with at least one. Without something like that, Eustace would be chunk salsa in 10 seconds. However, post-Narnia Eustace would be a more significant adversary. I think that Ed would win, but it would be a far more difficult fight for him. And pre-Narnia Ed vs. pre-Narnia Eustace would consist of girly fighthing with no one doing any real damage until Eustace happened to stub his toe or bump his head or something, and he would scurry off and tattle.

[Crimson]

I dont think Ed would automatically win..It depends like i said above if they were in Narnia, if back on earth...then maybe Edmund. but Eusatce was stronger in narnia then he was in earth

[noticeablyNARNIAN]

Rude Edmund vs. Rude Eustace?

Edmund. Rude Eustace is a total pansy.

and

King Edmund vs. Noble Eustace...

Ed. again. Edmund is just...idk, better?

[sk8ergurl]

I'm going to have to go with Edmund. I mean he is stronger.

[DjStickymuffinz]

EDMUND! O YEAH! he would win

[always winter]

definitely edmund.

if it was an annoying contest eustace would win, but other than that he comes off as coward and wimpy, edmund also has his wand breaking skills

[-Princess of the Bow-]

Defenitaly, Edmund!!

[Wendygirljp]

I guess my question is, "Why would they want to fight in the first place?"

I have seen this same kind of question in other areas as well - "Who would be beat the other in a fight - Jesus or the Buddha?" - Why would they fight in the first place, even if they lived in the same period of time, which they did not? They would probably spend time in philosophical discussion, laughter and joy.

[always winter]

I guess my question is, "Why would they want to fight in the first place?"

I have seen this same kind of question in other areas as well - "Who would be beat the other in a fight - Jesus or the Buddha?" - Why would they fight in the first place, even if they lived in the same period of time, which they did not? They would probably spend time in philosophical discussion, laughter and joy.

well if edmund was fighting eustace, perhaps it was before the brat learned to be nicer. heck, i'd throw eustace a punch in the face if i was stuck in the dawn treader.

[LifeMaiden]

I guess my question is, "Why would they want to fight in the first place?"

I have seen this same kind of question in other areas as well - "Who would be beat the other in a fight - Jesus or the Buddha?" - Why would they fight in the first place, even if they lived in the same period of time, which they did not? They would probably spend time in philosophical discussion, laughter and joy.


Why don't you post this Buddha vs Jesus in the Socratic section of our forum, and say Which philopsiphy would WIN?" LOLOL because we know that Buddha and Jesus wou;d NOT be beating each other up!

[Wendygirljp]

IceMaiden - asking whether Buddhism or Christianity would win would be like asking which would be better - ice cream or gasoline? They are not relevant from the point of comparison in the "debate" area, unless you wish to discuss which has "better ethics" - but as they teach the same basic ethics, the answer is going to end up, imho, a resounding "yes".

And again, which philosophy would win what? A fight? How funny! Thank you for making my evening with a bit more joy.

[-x-emo emz-x-]

Edmund!EDMUND!EDMUND! :p :p

[Yahtzee]

i think i could kick both their buts

[The Teacup]

Edmund he'll crash a cricket ball into Eustace's head and knock him out cold.

[sk8ergurl]

lol. u sure?

[Pevensie89]

Edmund, he's had the experiance of fighting in the Battle, and he's a king, and he's a Pevensie... :)

He had practise aswell, and because he's cool :D

[Jadee]

I wish I could see them fight!! (or read them) Edmund would win

[timbalionguy]

Interesting question. pre-Narnia, Edmond would beat Eustace effortlessly, and he would run off looking for some Plumtree Vitimanized Nerve Food.

Post LWW/VoDT? Edmund would still win, but it would be closer. Now, if Edmund had encountered Eustace as a dragon, the only way to tell is DNA evidence in Eustace dragon's droppings (and even that would be tough).

Post SC (no one has talked about that!), it would probably be a pretty even fight. Although Eustace still had some significant shortcomings in SC, he had matured a great deal and was much more the warrior.

[Lucy The Lionness]

I suppose Edmund, he's tougher and more determined. Eustace toughened up a bit but he's weak compared to Edmund!

[turkish delight-yummy]

deffinatley Edmund by far! mre experience so extra fighting will and power!

[WILLIAMS_QUEEN!!!!]

well i think that edmund would loose because hes weak!i think william would win.

[turkish delight-yummy]

hes sooooooooo not and anyway his goodlookingness would probably blind eustace making edmunb himself a deffinate winner! hehe

[~Lava~]

I am a new member of the forum. I pretty sure that Even when he was rude, Edmund would have won because in the Dawn Treader Lewis makes a point to say that even Lucy could win against Eustace.

[ACreepyPeterFangirl]

Uuuuhhh...I'd go with Edmund, since I've forgot all the other books with Eustace...

[Adanedhel]

wow this is an old thread. Edmund would kick butt.

[jkrowlingfan]

who's Eustace? sorry! *prepares for attack*

[Copperfox]

When Eustace was first introduced, it was stated that he was not capable of beating even Lucy in a fight, much less Edmund. Although his Narnian experiences doubtless made him as much physically tougher as morally better, I doubt he would have caught up with Edmund in the short career he had.

[Lila]

EDMUND!!!!! He sooo rocks.

[princejosh_thehonorable10]

umm, i think edmond, just because he was like king for twenty years, and had been in sooo many more wars and battles than eustace, but still eustace could do some damage, that is, after the voyage of the dawn treader

[the black elf]

um....well i dont know who the other dude is soooooo.....i'll say.....EDMUND!! :D
but i did hear that the other dude can change into a dragon which i have to say that is really cool!! :D

[Lila]

um....well i dont know who the other dude is soooooo.....i'll say.....EDMUND!! :D
but i did hear that the other dude can change into a dragon which i have to say that is really cool!! :D

yes, he did turn into a dragon in the dawn treader.