Who'd win in a fight, Skandar Keynes or William Moseley?

[office]

this one ihave no clue. so help me please.

[queenlucysbff]

William Moseley
Definatly, Skandar is too young to beat a 19 yr. old!

[makeascenerachel]

SKANDAR!!!!!!

CUZ sKANDAR IS SOO MUCH STONGER THAN WILLIAM CUZ I'M SORRY BUT WILL SUCKS

[truelovewaits]

skandar most definately!

[Will's Queen]

Hello? Are you all dumb? Will most definatly! He is so much better than Skander, with no affense to Skander! Love Ya, Will!

[Will's Queen]

You Rock, GeNtLe SuSaN!!!!!!!

[Lady Larien]

Will cause SK is ATHIEST!!!!!! >:l *gets very angry again* although i never really cooled off from what CT said about my dog. so automatically Will cause SK is dumb for not believing in God cause He brought him into this world and He can take him out

[makeascenerachel]

Will cause SK is ATHIEST!!!!!! >:l *gets very angry again* although i never really cooled off from what CT said about my dog. so automatically Will cause SK is dumb for not believing in God cause He brought him into this world and He can take him out
just cuz he's athiest doesn't mean we have 2 treat him different........he's just like us but only belives in something different

[.:~NikkitaTheJust~:.]

ya he's a normal teen like me...and others on here....gosh personally I love skandar but i think will would win... i mean really...

[skandarsgirl411]

that's sooooooooooooo true don't treat someone different just cause their not like you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and skandar would defenetly win she's sooooooooooooo mush stronger!!!!!!!!!!!!!! lol

[Wings of Vanity]

umm come on people- this is Will's win just look at the pic in my sig he is ripped!! come on he is incredibly strong and has years on Skandar!!

[Tooks]

skandar FOR SURE! cause i mean he's so hyper he can stomp anyone down without even noticing it! and he's WAYYY hotter then will! and its not his fault hes an athiest his great great great grandfather was charles darwin for goodness sake, i mean would you belive your family or go beliving someone else? we shouldn't judge him for what he belive in! at least he acts better then will( no offense to williamnites). hehehehe and skadarsgirl411 i think you said skandar was a she....

*there i said my part..now im tired of typing.....srry im a bit hyper....

[♣Teh Deviant♣]

Skandar isnt necesarrillly stronger, I mean, ppl, William is friggin' 18 (I think) years-old..but first off, they wouldnt BE in a fight.. :rolleyes:

[♣Teh Deviant♣]

I CHANGED MY MIND! OOH NO! BUT WAIT! WAIT! HAS ANYONE REALISED!??!?!
SKANDAR TAKES TAEK WAN DO LESSONS!!! GREEN BELT!WOOT!

[Jill Pole Queen of Narnia]

that's sooooooooooooo true don't treat someone different just cause their not like you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and skandar would defenetly win she's sooooooooooooo mush stronger!!!!!!!!!!!!!! lol

I think you just called Skandar a she LOL

[Faun 3.0]

Will cause SK is ATHIEST!!!!!! >:l *gets very angry again* although i never really cooled off from what CT said about my dog. so automatically Will cause SK is dumb for not believing in God cause He brought him into this world and He can take him out
Oh shut up!!!!! :mad:

I could beat both of the little pretty boys up, not that I want to. :D :D

[Jill Pole Queen of Narnia]

Oh shut up!!!!! :mad:

I could beat both of the little pretty boys up, not that I want to. :D :D
Are you angry?

[Crimson]

William Would Kick Skandars Butt!

[Jherek Normantry]

Will cause SK is ATHIEST!!!!!! >:l *gets very angry again* although i never really cooled off from what CT said about my dog. so automatically Will cause SK is dumb for not believing in God cause He brought him into this world and He can take him out


I personally think that it's because of people like you saying things like that that make the world look down on us and think what they think about us. An attitude like that drives them away even more, it doesn't help at all. It's people like you saying things like that, which makes me ashamed to call myself a christian.

[Oddish]

I'd rather be a corpse than an atheist, but I think you're all missing the point: this is a contest of physical skill and strength alone. We're assuming there won't be any divine intervention. And in that case, William would reduce Skandar to oatmeal. Sorry, Skandarites.

Of course, Reepicheep would whack both their fannies from here to Lantern Waste and back again, and he'd still have his tail after it was over. VIVA LA MAUS!!!

[Faun 3.0]

Are you angry?

How did you know? Was it the emoticons

Yes I'm angry, and I don't know why

[Princey]

Er, I am a WM fan but probably Skandar cos he does tae kwon do or something like that doesn't he? But WM's height could be an advantage to him cos let's face it, Skandar's puny compared to him.

[swashbuckle]

William definitely. Have you seen him topless?! Plus the fact he is about 5 years older. I don't quite think Skandar has the muscle power unfortunately.

[Faun 3.0]

it doesn't really matter.it's not like they would want to beat each other up

[~Grateful * Surrender~]

it doesn't really matter.it's not like they would want to beat each other up

I AGREE! but I still think Will would win :D

[Sharlene]

I think that William would win. he's older, and did more swordfighting scenes in the movie, plus he's taller and probably stronger too.
Why does it really matter though???

[Princey]

Lol I HAVE seen Will topless (aahh! =D what a sight it was!) but yeah, I don't think they would fight each other. And who cares anyway?

[~EdmundsQueen~]

Will cause SK is ATHIEST!!!!!! >:l *gets very angry again* although i never really cooled off from what CT said about my dog. so automatically Will cause SK is dumb for not believing in God cause He brought him into this world and He can take him out

OMG your basing your decision on him being an Athiest! i persoanlly think y'all who have changed your opinion or are sad/angry or pray that he'll become a christian or whatever are SAD! Just becuase he's an Athiest doesnt mean he's not like everyone else. Some people on here used ot love him and then when they found out he's a Athiest suddenly said "o i cant love an athiest!" Whats up with that? im an athiest and you havent treated me different so why are you treating him different.

I dont see what the big deal is about it. So what if he doesnt believe in anything. its not the end of the world

And for the record, Skandar would so win a fight against Will!

[GeNtLe SuSaN]

Duh!! William Moseley Would Win The Fight! He HAs Teh Swordsmanship Skills And He Is Way Hotter!!!!

[Princey]

Okay guys, this is getting out of hand! Just cos Skandar is an Athiest (sp?) doesn't mean he is in any way inferior to Will! I mean, I am a Christian myself but dude, chill, people believe what they believe!

[GeNtLe SuSaN]

Are you all blind???? Will would win without breaking a sweat!! YUR THE BEST WILL!!

CHECK THE GATE, WATCH YOURSELF, CHECK THE GATE, SHOW ME WATCHA GOT!

You rock to Will's Queen!!~!

[dwarfmaster77]

actually you are all blind, because Skandar is like 10 years old...lol his only chance is to kick him in "that certain place". but he still wouldn't win probably. will is so much older and bigger...it'd take 1 or 2 punches probably...

[lions mane]

and i just seen it! ya know?

with out a doubt will, hes older, stronger, and in better shape! it wont even be a match up! come on now! and will would never fight a 14 y/o i should think! i mean i never would and were basically the smae age!


come on people!

[Ks Girl]

actually you are all blind, because Skandar is like 10 years old...lol his only chance is to kick him in "that certain place". but he still wouldn't win probably. will is so much older and bigger...it'd take 1 or 2 punches probably...

Yep, I agree.

[Josh the Jester]

Okay girls you guys need to lay off with this who's better than who stuff, because its starting to bother me.

[NarniaFanatic]

Well, I think that William would win because he's taller and stronger than Skandar, but then again...Skandar is a green belt in Taw Kwon Do, so he might know a few techniques. ;)

But why would they fight, anyway? I mean, they're like brothers, aren't they?
So there would be no need for them to fight. :D

[lions mane]

omg! i posted earlier and forgot about the skands taw kwan doe (hope thats spelled right). nw i have no idea who would win! but i stil dont think that will will ever fight him being the fact that hes like 30 years older and all, and should be more mature then to fight someone that much younger then him! ya know? ;)

[~Rogue~]

I think Will would win cause all he'd have to do is tickle Skandar and Skandar would collapse and the fight would be over.

[.:~NikkitaTheJust~:.]

skandar is ticklish??? lol thats funny

[EveningStar]

Perhaps if we raised money for a substantial cash prize we could get them to duke it out. Please send cash to:

Mage Scribe Chakal
House of the Royal Magi
Dorton House, Apartment C
Cair Paravel 0372
NARNIA

[Dora_the_explora]

William Moseley
Definatly, Skandar is too young to beat a 19 yr. old!
I agree. But I still like Skandar more!

[Princey]

I dunno who would win, but I love Will. But Sk looks good with braces. And I thought Will was 18...wait was it his b'day this month? Some people think it's on September.

[peterismyking]

in all honesty, probably william, but skandar does seem like th ekind of person to have more anger, so i dont know, i dont really know them, so its hard to say :) I love Skandar :p

[Princey]

STOP MAKING ME LIKE SKANDAR! *puts hands over ears* Before I met you guys I hated him! And now look what your influencing has done! :P

[NarniaFanatic]

I think Will would win cause all he'd have to do is tickle Skandar and Skandar would collapse and the fight would be over.
No, even worse! Just give him a hug and he'll forfeit the match! :D
Group hug!

[Tooks]

lol but he did hug william in the end and it was on his own accord....soo it may not affect skandar as much....

but william does seem bigger then skandar...just a question but would anyone fight a person that is older then you 4-5 years older then you?

[Oddish]

NO TRYING TO GET SKANDAR AND WILL INTO A FIGHT!! If they get busted up, either "Prince Caspian" will be delayed :( or it will be called off :eek: or they'll have different actors as Peter and Ed :mad: .

And yes, Skandar did hug Will once, but it's easier for a hug-hater to give them than receive them, because you don't feel confined when you're giving one. I still believe the best way to beat Skandar in a fight is to give him that big Bear Hug!

[Princey]

Interesting, when did Skandie hug Will? (well, it isn't surprising, if I was there I'd hug Will myself, but yeah...)

[NarniaFanatic]

Interesting, when did Skandie hug Will? (well, it isn't surprising, if I was there I'd hug Will myself, but yeah...)
It talks about this in the audio commentary. You must listen to it!
Skandar hugged Will after the scene where Skandar got stabbed by the Witch and all his siblings were crying for him, even William! So William got so emotional in the scene where he had to cry that Skandar gave Will a hug when it was over! :D

[-Forever_Young-]

well I think Skandar would win, cuz he's skinnier and quicker. He could duck and dodge better :)

[Princey]

It talks about this in the audio commentary. You must listen to it!
Skandar hugged Will after the scene where Skandar got stabbed by the Witch and all his siblings were crying for him, even William! So William got so emotional in the scene where he had to cry that Skandar gave Will a hug when it was over! :D

AWW! That only proves how much Will is into acting....Not to self: Must listen to audio commentary

[i am preston]

u stupid head skander would win!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Queen Swanwhite]

william :) ;) :rolleyes:

[Isabel Moseley]

i think Will would win becaus he is older and anyways he is alot cuter :p

[truelovewaits]

meany poo heads! yall all know that skandar would win! he is 'da bomb! hehehe!

[miss_elizabeth]

of course it's skandar!! i lurve him!!!!!he was the best!!!!! :D :D :D

[Queen~Krista~the~Merciful]

SKANDAR!!!!!!

CUZ sKANDAR IS SOO MUCH STONGER THAN WILLIAM CUZ I'M SORRY BUT WILL SUCKS

I LOVE SKANDAR AND I WOULD NEVER SAY THAT WILLIAM SUCKS :mad: !! you just shouldnt say things like that :mad: !!

I LOVE SKANDAR

[skandarsgirl411]

skandar would sooooooooooooooooo win do i have to say this again?????????????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Empress Keynes]

Skandar would win! I know it!

[Lucy_QueenofNarnia]

Of course Will would win! He had more training for LWW, duh!!!!

[RevanRagnos]

Skandar, he seems pretty metal, and Will seems kinda like a sissy.

[cor fan14]

will most definitely :)

[~Rogue~]

Will seems to think he'd win..........

[Ephinie]

I'm pretty sure that Will would win. He's older, and when boys are around those two's ages, the older ones tend to be stronger and such.

Btw, Rogue... nice interviews. How do you do it? Do you think you'll be able to get one with Anna and Georgie perhaps?

[~Rogue~]

I'm pretty sure that Will would win. He's older, and when boys are around those two's ages, the older ones tend to be stronger and such.

Btw, Rogue... nice interviews. How do you do it? Do you think you'll be able to get one with Anna and Georgie perhaps?

I'm working VERY hard on it. So give me some time.

[SapphireOfSeptember]

What do you mean, verbally or physically?
I'd say SKANDAR either way. :) :cool: ;) :D

[PrinceOfTheWest]

I'm working VERY hard on it. So give me some time.
How about an interview with Lewis?

:D

[Lucy_QueenofNarnia]

Lewis!!? I hope you don't mean CS Lewis... he isn't exactly alive anymore....

[Oddish]

I read about an interview with Will, where he was asked that. I think he was vexed with Skandar at the time... he said he would win with his hands tied, blindfolded, and with his legs tied. For the record, I don't agree with this. I think the truth is probably as follows:

Unhandicapped Will vs. Skandar - Skandar gets scrambled. Will doesn't break a sweat.
Will with one hand tied vs. Skandar - Will wins, but gets somewhat bloodied up in the process.
Will with both hands tied vs. Skandar - Skandar wins. Probably. Will can kickbox, but Skandar's going to be ready for it.
Will with legs tied vs. Skandar - A toss-up, but Skandar would still be better advised to run away. Will will exhaust all his energy chasing him and then collapse, allowing Skandar to debilitate him with a flying elbow-drop off the top rope.
Will blindfolded vs. Skandar - Depends on how much Skandar talks. If he gives Will a voice to home in on, he's toast.
Will with two of the above handicaps vs. Skandar - Will might get a hit in, but Skandar will win. Sorry, Will, but you ain't that tough.
Will with hands and legs tied, blindfolded - Will is reduced to oatmeal. Skandar is subsequently beaten up by Anna.

[tumnus_luver15]

I read about an interview with Will, where he was asked that. I think he was vexed with Skandar at the time... he said he would win with his hands tied, blindfolded, and with his legs tied. For the record, I don't agree with this. I think the truth is probably as follows:

Unhandicapped Will vs. Skandar - Skandar gets scrambled. Will doesn't break a sweat.
Will with one hand tied vs. Skandar - Will wins, but gets somewhat bloodied up in the process.
Will with both hands tied vs. Skandar - Skandar wins. Probably. Will can kickbox, but Skandar's going to be ready for it.
Will with legs tied vs. Skandar - A toss-up, but Skandar would still be better advised to run away. Will will exhaust all his energy chasing him and then collapse, allowing Skandar to debilitate him with a flying elbow-drop off the top rope.
Will blindfolded vs. Skandar - Depends on how much Skandar talks. If he gives Will a voice to home in on, he's toast.
Will with two of the above handicaps vs. Skandar - Will might get a hit in, but Skandar will win. Sorry, Will, but you ain't that tough.
Will with hands and legs tied, blindfolded - Will is reduced to oatmeal. Skandar is subsequently beaten up by Anna.

lol
i agree with you oddish

[langtab]

Obviously Will, and not because Skandar is Athiest... BTW, im agnostic and I dont believe that im at a disadvatage in life because of it... Anywaysss... Definatly Will! :p

[xx_Williamgirly_xx]

I think the too of them are soooo sweet!!!
But, William is a little bit sweeter!!
He will win!!!

[xx_Williamgirly_xx]

I think Will win!"!!!
He's soooo sweet!!!! =)))

[Queen of the Lone Islands]

I really loooovvvvvveeeeeeeee Skandar,...but no, I still think Will would win in a fight :o

[Ginerva]

I think it would be William - definitely. He is 19, Skandar is 15. It's a bit too much for Skandar ;)

[Jargon]

that's sooooooooooooo true don't treat someone different just cause their not like you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and skandar would defenetly win she's sooooooooooooo mush stronger!!!!!!!!!!!!!! lol
this isn't about religion, Skander can beleive what he wants, but i still think William would win,...he held off the White witch, but Skander was still really cool.

[susanpevensie424]

Hello? Are you all dumb? Will most definatly! He is so much better than Skander, with no affense to Skander! Love Ya, Will!
Heck yeah! Will is 10 times better, and so much stronger. You go. Will, we love you!

[jesuschick]

Will!!!!!!! Duh!!!!!!!

[Moseleyfreak]

WILL would sooooo win!!!!!!!!!


We all love you!!!!!

[theorangejello]

lol will said he would win!!!
if anyone has seen rogue's interview.

[Lil'Narnia Freak]

I agree people need to understand this is the world.Not all people believe in god......but i do that's sooooooooooooo true don't treat someone different just cause their not like you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and skandar would defenetly win she's sooooooooooooo mush stronger!!!!!!!!!!!!!! lol

[the freak sisters]

Will would win!! Totally!! No offense Skander people, but willl is so much stronger and older(HOT!!!!!) He would win. All though they probably wouldn't fight anyway!! But if they did and most likley will would win!! If skander did win, anna would probably killl him!!! WILL IS SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO HOT ANd...(sexy!!! just kiddin!! BUT HE IS HOT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! No offense to skander by the way! WILL, YOU ROCK!! I LOVE YA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!

[the freak sisters]

Are all you guys nutz, Will would win. All he has to do is show his handsomness, and all the girls would vote WILL!

WILL YOU ROCK!

[benny]

i could take em both down...but yeah will would win if it was skandar and him

[the freak sisters]

The people who juging Skander becase hes a atheist, WELL DON'T, whoever is STUPID!

It's not his fualt
(Low Voice, I'm blaming his great grand father, he's an idiot, plus I don't care what Skander thinks)Treat him RIGHT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[benny]

i don't judge him! i think its kind im dumb but if he wants to do it let him people don't be dumb! lol

[Oddish]

Well, Skandar might win if he pulled out a Tommy-gun, but I'm assuming this squabble takes place in Britain, where even defending yourself with mace gets you 18 months in jail. Maybe a Samurai sword would do it, assuming those are even legal.

[i(l)william]

oh william would win just from his good looks. skandar will take one look at him a know that there is no posible way that he could ever beat some one with such good looks.

[Elf Of The Grey Havens]

So the question is: Who would win in a fight to the death between Skandar Keynes and William Moseley?
My answer: We all would.

[jesuschick]

Will duh!!

are you peoples blind???will would soooooooooooooooo win.(no offence)

[theorangejello]

Will duh!!

are you peoples blind???will would soooooooooooooooo win.(no offence)
WILL SAID HE WOULD!! IN ROGUE'S INTERVIEW WITH HIM!!! omg READ IT !!!!

[Elf Of The Grey Havens]

No one read/laughed at my reply.

[jesuschick]

So the question is: Who would win in a fight to the death between Skandar Keynes and William Moseley?
My answer: We all would.
hahahaha, :) there( i laughed but just did not type )

[theorangejello]

hahahaha, :) there( i laughed but just did not type )

okay to clear confusion
i'm a skandarnite
but if anyone here is INTELLIGENT
enough to have read rogue's interview with will in one question:

13.Who do you think would win in a fight between you and Skandar?
OMG oo that's a difficult question. Honestly? Or do I have to like lie?
Honestly, I could probably beat Skandar with my arms behind my back,
blindfolded and with both my feet tied together.

okay!!
that's why will would win... plus i have a cousin.. around skandars age and my bro is like a few months younger than will
guess who WON!!
MY BROTHER!!

[gah_its_hailey]

i love skandar but will wud soo win i menacum on look at the little bony king of nowhere then look at will no contest

[Lucy_QueenofNarnia]

Will's just older and stronger. There's no question. Although I'm sure Skandar would put up a nice fight.

[Princess_Iliana]

Will's just older and stronger. There's no question. Although I'm sure Skandar would put up a nice fight.

And you can't forget the heroic run! *sigh* I think Skandar would just get really mad. You know the part when Lucy comes to Peter in the middle of the night screaming " its all there like I told you!" And Peter pushes Edmund back and hes like " ow!!!" me and my friend were like "you wimp! That didn't hurt!"

[the freak sisters]

It is so sad!!! You guys think that will would win just because skander is athiast!!! If anything, you guys should be encouraging, not decieving!!! Its not his fualt that whats his name was his great great great grandfather!!!

And though i am sticking up for skander at the moment, i still think will would win. No offense to skander by the way! LOVE YA WILL!!

[the freak sisters]

:) OFFICIAL WILLIANITE!!
[COLOR=DarkGreen]Love Ya Will!!!

[gah_its_hailey]

It is so sad!!! You guys think that will would win just because skander is athiast!!! If anything, you guys should be encouraging, not decieving!!! Its not his fualt that whats his name was his great great great grandfather!!!

And though i am sticking up for skander at the moment, i still think will would win. No offense to skander by the way! LOVE YA WILL!!
i wasnt saying will wud win cuz skandar is an atheist i was saying hed win cuz he is stronger dont go accusing people of stuff they didnt say

[Jherek Normantry]

Skandar would difinately (sp?) win. Skandar takes Tea-kwon-do (sp?), and people in tea-kwon-do are trained to beat people that are both stronger and weaker, smaller or bigger, than themselfs. So logically, SKANDAR WINS!! haha

And just because Skandar's great x 4 or 5 is Charles Darwin, doesn't mean that Skandar has to be atheist, he can still be whatever religion he wants. But leave the religion out of it. So many people judge him by his atheism, and it makes me sick. Just drop it people.

[♣Teh Deviant♣]

Skandar would difinately (sp?) win. Skandar takes Tea-kwon-do (sp?), and people in tea-kwon-do are trained to beat people that are both stronger and weaker, smaller or bigger, than themselfs. So logically, SKANDAR WINS!! haha

And just because Skandar's great x 4 or 5 is Charles Darwin, doesn't mean that Skandar has to be atheist, he can still be whatever religion he wants. But leave the religion out of it. So many people judge him by his atheism, and it makes me sick. Just drop it people.

*watches as Jherek Normantry takes my words out of my mouth*
^_^ I totally, wholly, and completely agree.

[LifeMaiden]

I would say don't ever underestimate the person who is smaller physically, either :D . I didn't know Skandar took tae kwon do, but I know that James McEvoy ( Mr Tumnus) does a lot of kickboxing and martial arts.

[NarniaFan4eva]

I'm sorry i just have to say this:
Will cause SK is ATHIEST!!!!!! >:l so automatically Will cause SK is dumb for not believing in God cause He brought him into this world and He can take him out
Hey some people on this forum are athest too! :mad: I"M ATHEST! And i don't think religion has anything to do with this!
Anyway, i don't know who would win because there both strong in there own ways, like skandar's power is like combacks and stuff and will's is fit strong. (i'm not saying skandar isn't too.;))

[♣Teh Deviant♣]

I'm sorry i just have to say this:

Hey some people on this forum are athest too! :mad: I"M ATHEST! And i don't think religion has anything to do with this!
Anyway, i don't know who would win because there both strong in there own ways, like skandar's power is like combacks and stuff and will's is fit strong. (i'm not saying skandar isn't too.;))
Yeah. Like skandar would be good in a fightklub showdown. lmao Yo Mamma, thats sort of thing. :D

[NarniaFan4eva]

Yeah. Like skandar would be good in a fightklub showdown. lmao Yo Mamma, thats sort of thing. :D
lmao, yeah that does sound funny if you ut it that way, lol.

[Princess_Iliana]

Truly a never ending thread...

Who said anything aboutb Skandar losing because he is Athiest?
I still think William would win, for many reason, but it doesn't matter what your religion is to win a fight.... well in a physical fight, maybe not a mental fight, but I won't go into that.

[Clara Pendragon the Just]

king Of The Just And Magnificent

[Clara Pendragon the Just]

at first i like peter but now edmund

[Clara Pendragon the Just]

edmund rocks (http://) image

[Clara Pendragon the Just]

skandar keynes

[Emily_Cullen]

Will he is older and possibly stronger

[The First Joke]

if will and skandar were in a fight, i bet will would win. not because he's cooler, but because skandar doesn't want to embarass him.

[jumping joker]

i think will because he is older and looks more stronger than skandar

[Faun 3.0]

Size doesn't matter really. If Skandar knows the right places too hit, he'll win

[Princess_Iliana]

Size doesn't matter really. If Skandar knows the right places too hit, he'll win

That is an 'if' right? who knows, he might not know. *secretly laughs at Skandar*

[the freak sisters]

Skandar would difinately (sp?) win. Skandar takes Tea-kwon-do (sp?), and people in tea-kwon-do are trained to beat people that are both stronger and weaker, smaller or bigger, than themselfs. So logically, SKANDAR WINS!! haha

And just because Skandar's great x 4 or 5 is Charles Darwin, doesn't mean that Skandar has to be atheist, he can still be whatever religion he wants. But leave the religion out of it. So many people judge him by his atheism, and it makes me sick. Just drop it people.

Yhats true!! But in a way i still think will would win!!! But it would be a hard match but why would they fight anyway???? :confused: :confused:

[the freak sisters]

Are all you guys forgetting the question, the question is who'd do you think whould win in a fight Skander Kneyes or William Moseley?, not Who'd do you think is hotter Skander Kneyes or William Moseley?!!!!!!!!

[the freak sisters]

I think you spelled thats wrong, well anyway thanks for agreeing with me! :) :) :cool: :cool:

[The Valiant]

Hmm.....Im going with Skandar!

[peter and edmund lover]

hi i am fern im 12 and i have just registered :)

but i have to say both because i have always liked peter but now i have grown fond of edmund. :)

but i hate lucy :mad:
and i dont really like susan. :D


so my answer is both

[skandersluv]

Skandar will so win cuz the young always win!! duh! lol

[skandersluv]

me too I don't like her either she could be ayonning!!!

[Isabel Moseley]

well i would say william hes stronger older and smarter!!! :D

[stronger_WM]

Okay first of all..William Moseley is like a foot taller than Skandar, and about 30 lbs heavier. AND older. So yeah

William Moseley would win.

And I'm not just saying that.

[always winter]

hmm, well i think skandar will make the first successful attack. will would try to ignore skandar's little pranks and drink tea. skandar would continue fighting, then will would just get fed up with skandar and punch him out.

but yeah, i think overall, will would win. he said it himself "Honestly, I could probably beat Skandar with my arms behind my back, blindfolded and with both my feet tied together." will doesn't seem like the sort of person who would lie :p

[Protofan]

Will would win. 'Nuff said. Whoa...Deja Vu'

[cristy allysa]

They are both strong. I can't choose between the two.

[Queen Rocco]

this is hard hmmm william i donno why but i think he got the talant

[Queen Rocco]

hi i am fern im 12 and i have just registered :)

but i have to say both because i have always liked peter but now i have grown fond of edmund. :)

but i hate lucy :mad:
and i dont really like susan. :D


so my answer is both
that sexisisum you know?

[GeNtLe SuSaN]

hmm, well i think skandar will make the first successful attack. will would try to ignore skandar's little pranks and drink tea. skandar would continue fighting, then will would just get fed up with skandar and punch him out.

but yeah, i think overall, will would win. he said it himself "Honestly, I could probably beat Skandar with my arms behind my back, blindfolded and with both my feet tied together." will doesn't seem like the sort of person who would lie :p


EXACTLY!! HE WOULDN"T LIE BECAUSE HE"S SSSSSSSOOOOOOOOOOOO SINCERE!!! WILL WOULD MOST DEFINATLY WIN!!! END OF DISCUSSION! GOOD BYE! THE END!!!! ( oh, and one more thing! WILL WINS!!!) lol!

[AllAmericanGirl]

I honestly don't know. Most people would be "oh william would win" cause they like William and the same with Skandar. We will just all have to wait until the day they actually get into a fight. Watch it then see who the winner is lol :p :o.

[skander.in.my.dreams]

well skander is really hot. but william is much older, and phyically stronger, so i'd say william would win.
But in a "who's hotter contest" skander would defenatley win.

[SapphireOfSeptember]

i would say skandar all the way!

[The White Stag]

I'am not sure really it's hard because they are both good fighters but I would have to say William just because he is cute heee heee and that he is older. It's got nothing to do with how experienced they are because they both were practising their fighting skills at the same time. :eek:

[Lucy_QueenofNarnia]

well skander is really hot. but william is much older, and phyically stronger, so i'd say william would win.
But in a "who's hotter contest" skander would defenatley win.

in your dreams (obviously)

[Princess_Iliana]

well skander is really hot. but william is much older, and phyically stronger, so i'd say william would win.
But in a "who's hotter contest" skander would defenatley win.


*gasp!* I will restrain from saying anything mean.. must not say someting .. mean!... okay...

that is your opinion, about the 'who's hotter contest' and I'm okay with that, I just don't agree at all!

[lollypops36]

I think Will would win coz skandar is about my age and if a 19 year old tried to pick a fight with me they would win but I don't no them so i could be wrong but i don't think i am and it also depends on the kind of fight

[Lucy_QueenofNarnia]

I think Will would win coz skandar is about my age and if a 19 year old tried to pick a fight with me they would win but I don't no them so i could be wrong but i don't think i am and it also depends on the kind of fight

true- if it was like a verbal thing, skandar might have a chance-- he seems to be the outspoken one of the two-- but you never know, Will could be good at that...
but if it was anything with actual physical fighting, Will wins, hands down.

[skandersluv]

that is so true Skandar will so kicks Wills butt

[skandersluv]

that's sooooooooooooo true don't treat someone different just cause their not like you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and skandar would defenetly win she's sooooooooooooo mush stronger!!!!!!!!!!!!!! lol
Skandar will sooooooo win the fight!!!!!!

[mad-about-skandar-love-u]

okay so im just a girl named monica 12 yrs old and bornes 17 september 1993
im mad about skandar
1st-he's half lebanese which is the same as me and im proud of that
2nd-hes got cool hair
3rd-he likes blondes
4th-he enjoys been an actor [i want to be an actresse soon]
5th-got famous parents and familie on both sides
and at last he will definetly win the fight even tough i like blonde haired boys
but skander is going to be 15 in 75 days he's younger hotter buffer and cute
got 36 pics of him my bacground right now is of him

LOVE U SKANDARRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR I LUV SKANDAR KEYNES
I GOT HIS ADRESSE MIGHT VISIT HIM
LOVE HIS STYLE AND HIS NAME AT ELAST HE'S HALF LEBANESE
AND SAME HERE IM LEBANESE TOO [LOVE SKANDAR TILL IM AFTER DEATH]

[Elf Of The Grey Havens]

Ok... um... you went to the wrong place to introduce yourself.
And gave out too much info.

[Skanderluver]

well, i personally love skander a lot, but, i highly doubt a 15 year old can beat a 19 year old

[GeNtLe SuSaN]

I think WIll would win (which is my fourth time saying) cuz well, he's older and all, and he has a stinkin SIX-PACK!!! (look at my sig if you don't believe me!!)

[QueenSusanofNarnia]

Totally agree w/ GeNtLe SuSaN

WILL HAS A SIX PACK!!!I bet you 100,000 Galleons Skandar doesn't.

[GeNtLe SuSaN]

Totally agree w/ GeNtLe SuSaN

WILL HAS A SIX PACK!!!I bet you 100,000 Galleons Skandar doesn't.

I don't wanna know...I'm not looking! lol! Sorry skites!

[the freak sisters]

Skandar, he seems pretty metal, and Will seems kinda like a sissy.
A SISSY!!!!!??????
:mad:

[GeNtLe SuSaN]

A SISSY!!!!!??????
:mad:

I AGREE WITH HER!! WHAT DO YOU MEAN A SISSY?????????????? lol.
pfft...sissy.....yea right..................lol.

[smokeonthewater]

come on guys, be realistic. even though a lot of you may be in love with skandar or watever, how can you even entertain the idea that he could win against a nineteen-year-old? it's just kind of common sense. the people who have rooted for skandar only root for him because they are fans and really have no reasons supporting their answers.

WHAT DID SKANDAR OR WILL EVEN DO TO MAKE YOU ALL LOVE THEM SO MUCH? THEY WERE IN A MOVIE, OKAY? TAKE A DEEP BREATH AND GET OVER IT!!! this'll probably raise a gargantuan argument, but i personally think that skandar is one of the worst actors i have ever seen (and i mean for his age, too)

[Skandargrl4ever]

come on guys, be realistic. even though a lot of you may be in love with skandar or watever, how can you even entertain the idea that he could win against a nineteen-year-old? it's just kind of common sense. the people who have rooted for skandar only root for him because they are fans and really have no reasons supporting their answers.

WHAT DID SKANDAR OR WILL EVEN DO TO MAKE YOU ALL LOVE THEM SO MUCH? THEY WERE IN A MOVIE, OKAY? TAKE A DEEP BREATH AND GET OVER IT!!! this'll probably raise a gargantuan argument, but i personally think that skandar is one of the worst actors i have ever seen (and i mean for his age, too)

Oh no you didn't, this is not an argument, i'm just saying that in my opinion, skandar's one of the best actors i've ever seen and he's good looking, same with will, so i won't get over it, but even though i'm a skandar fan, it's kinda impossible for him to beat will, just saying

[QueenSusanofNarnia]

I don't wanna know...I'm not looking! lol! Sorry skites!

i'd look...:) haha...:)

But i do think Will'd win...

[QueenSusanofNarnia]

come on guys, be realistic. even though a lot of you may be in love with skandar or watever, how can you even entertain the idea that he could win against a nineteen-year-old? it's just kind of common sense. the people who have rooted for skandar only root for him because they are fans and really have no reasons supporting their answers.

WHAT DID SKANDAR OR WILL EVEN DO TO MAKE YOU ALL LOVE THEM SO MUCH? THEY WERE IN A MOVIE, OKAY? TAKE A DEEP BREATH AND GET OVER IT!!! this'll probably raise a gargantuan argument, but i personally think that skandar is one of the worst actors i have ever seen (and i mean for his age, too)

well, actually, I'm only 13, I only wiegh 89 lbs., and i'm only 5'1" and I"m quite skinny (my right wrist measures 2inches in diameter--i think) and i can beat up a 15-year-old.
but i still do think that will would win (this is a tough decision for someone who is both a Willianite and a Skandarnite!!)

[iamperfectlyme]

id have to say will because hes bigger, older, and has a six pack. Skandar is kinda little. I mean common sense.

[the freak sisters]

I AGREE WITH HER!! WHAT DO YOU MEAN A SISSY?????????????? lol.
pfft...sissy.....yea right..................lol.

Thanks!! And lets take a DEEP breath and get it over withK? I used to be overly obbsesed w/ Will and now I'm not c???? He was an actor!!! And its more likely that will would win cuase hes older. But Skander is in TKD!! Sooo who knows and who cares??? :confused:

Unless u live in the same country as them (Unlike me) u MOST LIKELY wont meet them!!! Just take a DEEP BEREATHE!!! K???

[theorangejello]

are we still debating over this.. my god.. someone should just request them to have a stage fight on prince caspian!!
this IS GETTING OLD!!

[tottyfruitty]

well i think that Will would win because he is
stronger(six pack and muscles as prrof or just look in my siggy)
cleverer
older
and hotter(it had to be said)
:D

[the freak sisters]

Im sorry if I keep coming back to the subject but does anyone get it?????!!!! MAD! The question was and is NOT who is hotter or who is better it was simply asking, who do u think and why? Whats the more logical answer??? Just Listen! I know ill probably get killed for this but u ppl know what i mean!!!!

[Lucy_QueenofNarnia]

Wow... didn't know this thread was still around, lol.

Will would win just because he's bigger. He's stronger.

[the freak sisters]

are we still debating over this.. my god.. someone should just request them to have a stage fight on prince caspian!!
this IS GETTING OLD!!


ture!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Gentle Voice]

william will win any time because he can :p

[office]

i have no opinion here.

[SlpNarniaQueen]

Sooooooooooo Will...I was reading an interveiw and he said he could beat skandar blinfolded with his hands tied behind his back and his legs tied together... :eek:

[~RG Lover~]

will! definitely! ;)

he can beat skandar just by looking at him, all skandar has to do is look at will and wills good looks would knock skandar out! :cool:

[ramandu's_daughter]

Skandar, really, because in the books Edmund is the most feared among the enemies because he is the most skilled knight in Narnia. Also, Will looks pretty cocky. Everything would all go to his head and he wouldn't be able to focus.

*Note to that person who said Skandar's atheist: he can believe what he likes. He may be saved one day but til then, stick to your own biz. By the way an atheist goes 2 my church cuz his parents make him LOL i'm episcopalian

[*Hobbit*]

hi i am fern im 12 and i have just registered :)

but i have to say both because i have always liked peter but now i have grown fond of edmund. :)

but i hate lucy :mad:
and i dont really like susan. :D


so my answer is both
How dare you,you should be ashamed of yourself that is the worst thing I have ever heard on this website,take that post of right now,Oh and welcome to narnia fans.com lets be friends.

[~Sweet Angel~]

Will's gonna win 'cause he's bigger and stronger.

[Miss.SunFlower]

will + fight x skandar = TIE!

[<Turkish Delight>]

Even though I am both a Will and Skandar fan I think William would win cause he is older and stronger. Sorry Skandar. :(

[Twilight]

William Moseley would win because, well, he's older and probably much stronger as well!

[AlfredtheGreat]

Will He's older

[ILSE]

I think Will, I hope Skandar :D

[The_real_queen_of_Narnia]

just cuz he's athiest doesn't mean we have 2 treat him different........he's just like us but only belives in something different

THAT'S RIGHT. Plus it's not his fault that he was born into a family that does not believe in God....







SKANDAR!!!!!!

CUZ sKANDAR IS SOO MUCH STONGER THAN WILLIAM CUZ I'M SORRY BUT WILL SUCKS

Now really. You know that Will is stronger. I mean he's 19 for crying out loud. I love Skandar but some things are obvious. Just because you love Skandar more than Will doesn't mean he's actually stronger, ya know.

[Red Roses]

are u ppl blind! will would win hands down!

[Red Roses]

besides i think u ppl are being unfair to Skandy. its not his fault that hes atiest. i blame his great great something grandfater.

[hello mcfly]

I agree, its not his fault! But what we can do is keep praying for him and maybe he'll find God someday! Who knows? Btw, I think Skandar can win too!

[Lady Narnia]

Fair fight, both ways. Skandar and William are both very capable!

[The_real_queen_of_Narnia]

I agree, its not his fault! But what we can do is keep praying for him and maybe he'll find God someday! Who knows? Btw, I think Skandar can win too!

*pondering* maybe we could like put him in a room with only a bible and ACCIDENTALLY lock him in and ACCIDENTALLY tell him we lost the key... and maybe he will be so bored that he will pick up the bible and read it and get to the part when God explains faith and all of that.... ummmm..... :D Just joking. I pretty much don't care if he is athiest. like if he would be one of my friends i wouldn't treat him any different. But we can still pray though cuz i don't want him to go to hell. I mean he is not that much of a hateful or selfish person to deserve to go to hell...

[hello mcfly]

*pondering* maybe we could like put him in a room with only a bible and ACCIDENTALLY lock him in and ACCIDENTALLY tell him we lost the key... and maybe he will be so bored that he will pick up the bible and read it and get to the part when God explains faith and all of that.... ummmm..... :D Just joking. I pretty much don't care if he is athiest. like if he would be one of my friends i wouldn't treat him any different. But we can still pray though cuz i don't want him to go to hell. I mean he is not that much of a hateful or selfish person to deserve to go to hell...

Lol! Im not that mean! :p haha! I have friends that are from different cultures, but I would never treat them any different...

[Darth Sparhawk]

Very weird topic. I hope that they will never fight. About the question, William is much older and bigger, he would probably win, but again, two great actors, I hope that they never will fight.

[tottyfruitty]

me too but Will would win. i am not so sure about the bigger part cos skandar is really tall now.

[Red Roses]

how about we just sit and pray that they never get into a fight cuz they would probably not be able to film prince caspian. :eek: we can't have that happen

[Red Roses]

we could also sit and pray and just hope that skander finds god someday :rolleyes:

[Darth Sparhawk]

Yeah, but I wouldn't worry about the fight, they are intelligent kids and from what I saw from the film about the movie making, the Pevensie actors love each other.

[Red Roses]

true enough :D

[Red Roses]

seems like every1 tired of this subject :rolleyes:

[MrsKeynes x3]

I think Will would win against Skandar. He's taller, stronger and older. But don't get me wrong, I LOVE the Skan-Man. It's just that Will has much more advantages.
But I don't think we ever have to worry about that. They're practically brothers.
Although, if you listen to the interview Rogue had with William, he was saying some really mean things about Skandar and for a while I thought they were mad at each other. But now I just think that he was messin' around. All friends mess around, you know? It's typical.

[Darth Sparhawk]

They were kidding. Will was kidding. have you watched the movie about the movie? These kids, all of them, they love each other, like true family. ;)

[Wunderkind]

They were kidding. Will was kidding. have you watched the movie about the movie? These kids, all of them, they love each other, like true family. ;)
Yeah...that's so sweet! :)
But umm...I think Will would win in a fight..(sorry Skandie)

[the freak sisters]

*pondering* maybe we could like put him in a room with only a bible and ACCIDENTALLY lock him in and ACCIDENTALLY tell him we lost the key... and maybe he will be so bored that he will pick up the bible and read it and get to the part when God explains faith and all of that.... ummmm..... :D Just joking. I pretty much don't care if he is athiest. like if he would be one of my friends i wouldn't treat him any different. But we can still pray though cuz i don't want him to go to hell. I mean he is not that much of a hateful or selfish person to deserve to go to hell...


Nice Plan! LOL, but u r right! And, this whole thing on who would win is apparently very old, so I really am not going to argue anymore!

QV

[Edmundisamazing]

Skandar would win because he is just that amazing. He could beat up Will just by looking at him.

How ironic that a great great great ect grandson of Charles Darwin would be playing the character that represents the Christian life. I'd say that's a slam against Satan right there. Anyway, hopefully, Skandar will come to Jesus.

[Copperfox]

Reality time. The production book told how slow Skandar was to pick up weapon techniques. William would make sushi out of him.

[Pirate Queen]

I would say Will just from what I've read.

But it looks like this thread is based on whoever is hotter would win.

[Octesian]

Reality time. The production book told how slow Skandar was to pick up weapon techniques. William would make sushi out of him.

Agreed, William would win. no doubt

[Mrs. Pevensie]

I don't think taking into account how long it took them to pick up skills...what matters is how good they got. At least in the movie I think Skandar had a lot more parts that showed awesome skills. Like in the cave when he's fighting the wolf and when he's weilding double swords during battle. And fighting Trumpkin! Skandar would win hands down. I think that would be an interesting fight to watch!

[office]

Haha wow I can`t believe how young and dumb I was when I created this thread.:D This thread is so old and I can`t believe that people are still discussing this. Anyways I still have no idea who would win.

[Danny93]

HAHA this is a great thread! my sister says that Skander would win, but i have to say thats NOT true. Will would definetly win! although it may take a little while! mind i said LITTLE!;)

[EveningStar]

They did fight once, but it's unclear who won since Skandar's pillow burst and feathers went everywhere, while William kept right on swinging... :D:D

(not!)

[Danny93]

HAHAHA thats great! i would love to see that happen!!!:D

[the freak sisters]

It would be an interesting fight . . .

(I found this thread way back under one of my old posts, and decided to try saying something again!! :) )
QV

[tolkienlewisfan]

William would win hands down.

[Fifth Pevensie]

Will, at least for now. He's been described as athletic and, you know, trained in Brooklyn with boxing and stuff. But, give him a couple of softie roles, and Skander continuing to grow taller and ever more daring, then I really wouldn't know.

Ok, maybe it'd still be Will --just because he's so enthusiastic about squeezing the life out of Skander in hugs etc. :D

[Llama-Llama-Duck]

hahahhaha nice idea for a thread.

My vote's on Will. (Take that, Skandarnites! bwa ha ha)

[~Lava~]

Will has more strength and muscle because he is older, it really depends on the fight though.

[the freak sisters]

WHAT DID SKANDAR OR WILL EVEN DO TO MAKE YOU ALL LOVE THEM SO MUCH? THEY WERE IN A MOVIE, OKAY? TAKE A DEEP BREATH AND GET OVER IT!!!

^By smokeonthewater^

Hey, that's kinda true, what did they do to make us all love them??? Idk, but I think they are both very talented actors, and hot and cool and all but face it, Will is older and possibly stronger though Skandar is in Karate, so either way but it would be an interesting fight.... :)

[Fifth Pevensie]

Ah! I did not know Skander took karate. That changes things.... but not much. :p

I still call Will as the victor.

[Red Roses]

LOL! Who revived this thread? :p:confused:

Will would win. He's older and stronger and just... He would win. ;)

[the freak sisters]

Haha, I revived it!!! :) I found it in my old posts and decided to post again!! Mo-ha-ha!

And even though Skandar is in Karate, which would be helpful for him, I think Will would win . . . stronger, i think . . . . and older!

QV

[Tweetsie]

Mmm. SKANDAR WOULD BEAST.

Depends on what the fight is though. If it's like an awesomeness fight Skandy wins, if it's a physical fight, Skandar still wins.

[Llama-Llama-Duck]

Is this a fight to the death?

[Fifth Pevensie]

^Never!

Just, you know, to the point of utter and total humiliation. (Sorry Skandarnites I still think Will's got the lead here).

Although once he finishes his medical education he would have a very strong advantage. :D

[~indira~]

SKANDAR DEFINITLEY!!!!

i agree w/ tweetsie =]

He seems better w/a sword [if its a sword fight]
and if its a physical fight, he still wins [he totally got won that fight in pc when peter was getting beaten up by those boys <--beginning (eventhough its still a movie..psh!)]

XD XD XD XD XD XD XD XD XD XD

[DaughterofRamandu]

Oh I think Will would win actually. But that doesn't diminish my love of Skandar!!!

[the freak sisters]

Yeah, it would be interesting; but with the fact that Will's is older and stronger, I think he would win; close call, since Skandar's in Karate. Oh well,

("They're both hot anyways" - my friend)

Love
QV
AKA
The First And Only Freak Sista

[KingPeterFan122]

Moseley!
(you see the abs on that thing? LOL)

[I_Believe]

To me its a draw. Will is strong but a stronger guy dosn't always win. You gotta be smart too. You got to get in the other opponets head. Anticapte there next move. And this could be just me but..... Skandar looks smart. So who knows. Inless it really happenes all we can do is guess. Can you tell i thought about this way to much???

[Narnia_Lover_4_ever]

I um dont know I would say skandar actually cause if you think about it. Skandar looks skinnier but um GEORGIE was prone to beat will up! HELLO!!!!!!! :eek: So yeah i say skandar for obvious reasons. My friends think wills girlish:( I think hes buff!:D


So id go with both cuse will is older but that doesnt mean anything. I really dont know

[Narnia_Lover_4_ever]

Moseley!
(you see the abs on that thing? LOL)

Please I get CHILLS just thinking about them looking at them I start to shriek hysterically!

[Narnia_Lover_4_ever]

oh i think will would win actually. But that doesn't diminish my love of skandar!!!

can anything diminish our love for skandar!?!?!??!?! I think not!!!!

[Lord of Light]

Ummm....after both Will and Skandar having been well trained and both of them having excersized for the movies, I imagine that they'd both knock each other flat!:D

[Catherine]

Skandar, because he's like in tae-kwon-do or karate or something like that.

[Darth Sparhawk]

BTW, Wiliam studied kick-box before Caspian, so this advantage for Scandar is non-existent now.

[eustace_lover]

Skandar Keynes because William looks like a scaredy cat.:D

[loverble]

I think it would be Will because he is older and he is also stronger. Will has done a lot more fighting practice. Sorry Skandar. We love you. But Will is bigger and stronger. He has done all the sword fighting and the boxing and stuffs like that... Even with Skandars Tae Kwon Do. Well it dose depend wheather or not he is into the fighting side or the Poomsae.

Now Will and Ben are more fairly matched.

[Shadow_Kitty]

photographic evidence:

[Lord of Light]

Uh...I don't get why it matters...:D

[CaptainLiecy]

I reckon Will coz he's got wayy bigger muscles and he's taller
also i dont think will and ben would be more evenly matched, ben's too skinny (but ultra hot tho.... so's will ;))
and i'm not saying will's fat either

[Terabithian_Authoress]

Will. cus the Fan-girls would beat Skandar up to pieces! I would! *not*

[NarnianQueen6]

I don't know, it might be fairly evenly matched. It sounds like both have experience in some sort of fighting skills! Although, I do think Will has an edge... it seems like he's a lot more active that Skandar!

[SusanTheGentleHornblower]

rofl!! the pic is hilarious! :D I'd say it'd be a good fight, but Skandar would lose. Don't get me wrong, he rocks, and personally I liked him better in PC than Will, but Will's bigger. cha. he'd win.

[office]

Uh...I don't get why it matters...:D

It doesen`t. I made this like two and a half years ago.